NAO publishes report on BSF

20 March 2009

On 12 February 2009 the National Audit Office published its report entitled "The Building Schools for the Future Programme - Renewing the secondary school estate."

The report finds that 78 per cent of Local Authorities and 86 per cent of companies involved in the Building Schools for the Future (BSF) programme believe that it is leading to more strategic procurement of school infrastructure than previous school building programmes. Local Authorities are using BSF to rearrange the location, type and number of schools in their area and create facilities and school environments which support their educational objectives. BSF schools are built to higher specifications and space standards than previous schools; though until post occupancy reviews take place a year after each opens it is too early to say whether they will meet user expectations. 

The report also finds that DCSF and Partnerships for Schools (the body established by DCSF to manage the BSF programme centrally) were too optimistic in their assumptions of how quickly the first schools could be delivered. By December 2008, only 42 of the planned 200 schools had been built, with 54 due to open next year and 121 the year after. To include all schools in the programme, 250 schools will need to be built a year and the number of schools in procurement and construction at any one time will need to double from 2011 onwards. The extent to which problems in the finance markets will affect BSF is still unclear. 

DCSF and Partnerships for Schools estimate that the total cost of renewing the school estate will be between £52 billion to £55 billion which is £7 billion to £10 billion more than was estimated at the outset of the programme. DCSF has increased the scope of the programme and building cost inflation has been higher than originally estimated, but the cost of individual schools has been contained at a level similar to previously built PFI schools.

Tim Burr, head of the National Audit Office, said: "Building Schools for the Future is a highly ambitious £55 billion programme. Converting that ambition to reality requires robust planning, close cost control and making a success of complex long-term partnerships. Partnerships for Schools and the Department were too optimistic in their early plans though programme management has since improved. But it remains a real challenge, in difficult market conditions, to deliver the 250 schools a year that will be needed, to include all schools by 2020 as currently planned."

Click here for a copy of the report. Click here for minutes of discussion of the report by the Committee for Public Accounts 23 February 2009.

« back